Mrthfx

Trying to use space on a page more economically, I developed the idea to arrange graphics as a table being part of a figure. As I still wanted to refer to individual graphics, I also wanted to have captions for each such sub-graphic.

(Only after I had problems, I realized that there does exist a similar mechanism, also named subfigure and subcaption)

(I'm no TeX expert, I only know LaTeX a bit)

The code shown below outputs the references as Text... 1 (1.2) ... 1 ...
Text... 1 (1.3) ... 1, so the sub-caption numbers are wrong, while the main caption number is correct. The intended output is Text... 1.2a (1.2) ... 1.2b ...
Text... 1.3a (1.3) ... 1.3b.

The captions for the example code read (numbers are correct there):

Abbildung 1.1: Caption0



Abb. 1.2a: Caption1a    Abb. 1.2b: Caption1b

Abbildung 1.2: Caption1



Abb. 1.3a: Caption2a    Abb. 1.3b: Caption2b

Abbildung 1.3: Caption2

So here's the input for this example (use any placeholder graphic for Platzhalter.pdf):

documentclass[a4paper,twoside]{report}

usepackage{german}

usepackage[latin1]{inputenc}

usepackage{a4}

usepackage{makeidx}

usepackage{showidx}

usepackage{amsmath}

usepackage{url}

usepackage{graphicx}

usepackage{ifthen}

%

newcounter{subfigureX}[figure]

renewcommand{thesubfigureX}{thefigurealph{subfigureX}}

newcounter{savefigure}

newcommand{gtLab}{}

newcommand{gtCap}{}

%

newenvironment{gfxTableCapLab}[4][htbp]{%

ifthenelse{equal{#4}{}}%

{renewcommand{gtLab}{}}%

{renewcommand{gtLab}{label{#4}}}%

ifthenelse{equal{#3}{}}%

{renewcommand{gtCap}{fLab}}%

{renewcommand{gtCap}{caption{gtLab{}#3}}}%

begin{figure}[#1]%

setcounter{savefigure}{value{figure}}%

stepcounter{figure}%

begin{center}%

begin{tabular}{#2}}%

{end{tabular}%

setcounter{figure}{value{savefigure}}%

gtCap%

end{center}

end{figure}%

}

%

newcommand{gLab}{}

newcommand{gCap}{}

%

newcommand{gfxCapLab}[4]{%

ifthenelse{equal{#4}{}}%

{renewcommand{gLab}{}}%

{renewcommand{gLab}{label{#4}}}%

ifthenelse{equal{#3}{}}%

{renewcommand{gCap}{gLab}}%

{renewcommand{gCap}{parnoindentgLabsubcaption{#3}}}%

begin{minipage}[t]{#1textwidth}%

{centeringincludegraphics[width=textwidth]{#2}}%

gCap%

end{minipage}%

}

%

newcommand{gfxCap}[3]{gfxCapLab{#1}{#2}{#3}{}}

%

newcommand{subcaption}[1]{%

%steprefcounter{subfigureX}

addtocounter{subfigureX}{1}%

{small Abb.~thesubfigureX: #1}%

}

begin{document}

chapter{Chap}

%

begin{figure}

  Test

  caption{Caption0}

end{figure}

begin{gfxTableCapLab}{lr}{Caption1}{label1}%

gfxCapLab{0.4}{Platzhalter.pdf}{Caption1a}{label1a}

&

gfxCapLab{0.4}{Platzhalter.pdf}{Caption1b}{label1b}

end{gfxTableCapLab}

%

Text...

ref{label1a} (ref{label1}) ... ref{label1b} ...



begin{gfxTableCapLab}{lr}{Caption2}{label2}%

gfxCapLab{0.4}{Platzhalter.pdf}{Caption2a}{label2a}

&

gfxCapLab{0.4}{Platzhalter.pdf}{Caption2b}{label2b}

end{gfxTableCapLab}



Text...

ref{label2a} (ref{label2}) ... ref{label2b}

end{document}

Specifically pdflatex complains if I uncomment the line %steprefcounter{subfigureX} (commenting addtocounter{subfigureX}{1} instead):

! Undefined control sequence.

subcaption #1->steprefcounter 

                                {subfigureX} {small Abb.~thesubfigureX : #1}

l.68 ...{0.4}{Platzhalter.pdf}{Caption1a}{label1a}

(Originally I had named my counter subfigure also, but then I discovered that a counter with such a name already exists, so I appended the X).

Preferably the answer contains an explanation why my code does not work (everything that is wrong), how to do it correctly, and (as an extra) how I could achieve the same effect using the stock subfigure and subcaption mechanisms.